Tuesday, September 20, 2011
1st Circuit gives basic copyright lesson for software creators
Those are the lessons from the recent First Circuit decision in Airframe Systems, Inc. v. L-3 Communications Corp., No. 10-2001 (1st Cir. Sept. 14, 2011). The plaintiff Airframe hadn’t taken these easy steps, and it lost an otherwise perfectly good copyright infringement case as a result.
Here’s what happened. Airframe registered the original software code, then licensed defendant L-3 to use that code. Over time, as its clients changed or upgraded their computer operating systems, Airframe routinely modified its software to work on these new platforms. But it did not register the code for the modified versions. When L-3 upgraded its computer system, it somehow got ahold of a newer, non-registered version of the code and used that as the basis to modify its licensed code to be compatible with the new computer system. Airframe found out and sued.
L-3 filed a motion for summary judgment, arguing there was no evidence it infringed. Airframe put in an affidavit showing how similar L-3’s software was with a modified but unregistered version of the copyrighted software. The court didn’t explain why Airframe didn’t compare the infringing code to the original, registered code. Maybe it didn’t have a copy; maybe it didn’t think to do so. In any event, the trial court thought this was a fatal error. Airframe appealed to the First Circuit Court of Appeals.
Airframe got no sympathy from the appeals court. The First Circuit first noted that copyright holders can sue only if they have registered the copyright in the infringed work. It then explained that to prove infringement, a plaintiff has to prove both “factual copying” of the registered work and “substantial similarity.” The 1st Circuit ruled that Airframe never proved the content of its registered software (i.e., the original version), so it couldn’t, as a matter of law, establish “factual copying” of the registered work. It didn’t matter that L-3’s software was substantially similar to a modified, unregistered version, because that didn’t prove that L-3’s software was substantially similar to the original, registered version.
So, to repeat the important lessons here:
(1) It’s not enough to register the copyright in the original source code. When you modify it, register the modified versions too; and
(2) Retain copies of all prior versions because you never know which one you might need in an infringement case.